Are Marketers Using AI to Make More Content or Better Content?


Partner


AI has made it easier for marketers to produce more content, faster. But creating more content doesn't necessarily mean creating better marketing. As brands invest in generative and agentic AI, marketing leaders face a question about what they want the technology to accomplish.

During my interview with Aaron Mitchell Finegold, Adobe's head of product marketing for GenStudio, Firefly Enterprise, and Adobe Brand Intelligence, at Adobe MAX, he shared a framework he'd developed earlier that day for thinking about how AI can support creative professionals.

"The goal is always making creative better, right? That's the North Star," he said.

His framework identifies three opportunities for agentic AI: generating insights that inform creative decisions, preserving creative intent as content moves through production, and giving teams more time to develop original ideas. The underlying principle is that people should determine what gets created and why, while AI helps them bring those ideas to life.

Using AI to inform creative decisions

The first opportunity is using AI agents to give creative teams information they can act on throughout the creative process. Finegold described two types of insights: understanding audiences and culture, and identifying which creative elements contribute to campaign performance.

AI agents can analyze emerging conversations on social platforms, competitor activity, and what consumers are likely to find compelling or inauthentic. Rather than relying exclusively on historical campaign results, creative teams could use these insights to inform ideas before content enters production.

Agents can also identify combinations of creative elements associated with stronger campaign performance. For example, an agent could analyze several weeks of campaign data to identify combinations of colors, borders, layouts, and spacing associated with better performance. Previously, a team might know that a LinkedIn campaign performed well without understanding which elements contributed to its success.

With more detailed creative performance data, teams could make more informed decisions about what to keep, change, or test in future campaigns.

Preserving the original idea as content scales

The second opportunity addresses a problem that becomes more complicated as marketing teams produce content for more channels, audiences, and markets. An original campaign concept might begin with a creative director or designer before passing through multiple teams responsible for adapting it into different formats.

"There is a real risk of dilution of that original creative intent as things get personalized—as things get localized," Finegold said.

He sees an opportunity for AI agents to help maintain that intent throughout production, even as content is adapted for different formats, languages, and audiences. AI agents can help preserve the original creative intent as teams adapt and distribute content across different channels, formats, and audiences.

Giving creative teams more time to develop ideas

The third opportunity is one of AI's most familiar promises: reducing production work so people can spend more time on creativity. But Finegold argues that generative AI hasn't always delivered on that promise. A standalone generative model can produce an image or short video from a prompt, but the output may require significant revisions before it's ready for professional use.

Agentic AI presents a different possibility. Unlike standalone generative models that create assets from prompts, AI agents can work directly within professional applications such as Photoshop, Premiere Pro, and After Effects. By using these tools' existing editing and production capabilities, agents can complete tasks with greater precision, potentially reducing the time creative teams spend on technical execution.

Finegold explained that AI-generated content requiring extensive corrections doesn't save creative teams time. Agents that can perform tasks directly within professional creative tools could reduce that extra work, giving teams more time to develop original ideas.

Creative judgment remains the priority

Finegold's framework also reflects a broader concern about how marketing leaders evaluate AI investments. He believes marketers sometimes underestimate the aesthetic judgment involved in creative work, particularly when an original campaign needs to be adapted across multiple channels.

Even when the central idea has already been approved, decisions about how it should look, sound, and communicate remain important.

"The value of aesthetics and the value of things looking and sounding like the way the brand wants to be expressed in a way that's gonna actually resonate doesn't change when you scale," he said.

Finegold believes humans should continue to set a brand's creative vision and decide which ideas are worth pursuing. AI agents can support that work by analyzing information, handling production tasks, and preserving creative intent throughout the process.

For marketing leaders, the value of agentic AI comes from improving the creative process, not simply increasing output. Finegold's framework offers three ways to put that principle into practice, with human judgment guiding the work from concept to completion.


Let's Connect!