🚨 Exactly how Google judges your content now


Hello Reader!

You've heard the news.

Google’s quality raters are now flagging AI-generated content as the lowest quality. (Took them long enough, right?)

According to SEL, in its January 2025 update to the Search Quality Rater Guidelines, Google directed raters to label content as Lowest quality if it's clearly AI-generated, paraphrased, or lacks originality and value.

Here's what Google will be looking for (here's a checklist you can download to give your content peeps):

  • AI-generated or auto-generated content: Main content is created using AI or automation with little to no human effort.
  • Lack of originality or value: Content adds no unique insights or usefulness for users.
  • Self-serving page purpose: Pages created mainly to benefit the site owner, not the visitor (e.g., for ad revenue).
  • Expired domain abuse: Repurposing expired domains to host thin, low-quality content.
  • Site reputation abuse: Publishing third-party content to benefit from a host site's existing rankings.
  • Scaled content abuse: Producing large amounts of low-effort, unedited, or auto-generated content.
  • Paraphrased content: Restating other sources without adding anything new or insightful.
  • Common or duplicated facts: Heavy overlap with well-known information from sources like Wikipedia.
  • Summarized content: Pages that repackage forum threads or news without additional value.
  • AI indicator language: Phrases like “As an AI language model” may signal auto-generated content.
  • Filler content: Visually dominant but unhelpful content that clutters the page and distracts users.
  • Poor content layout: Layouts that make it harder to access relevant information quickly.
  • Exaggerated creator claims: Inflated credentials or misleading claims about the content creator.
  • Unverified expertise: Statements of authority or personal experience that lack proof.
  • Social reposts: Pages made of reposted social content with little or no commentary.
  • Uncurated embeds: Pages with videos or images embedded from other sources without added context.
  • Unoriginal “best of” lists: Lists copied from other reviews or rankings with minimal new input.
  • Recipe page clutter: Recipe pages filled with ads or unrelated content that disrupts the user experience.
  • Ad blocker requirement: Raters must turn off ad blockers when evaluating pages for accurate assessments.

I'm hoping this works and sticks. As a content marketer, the ease of getting garbage content to rank has been disheartening.

If something can be fully-AI generated, it's not worth publishing anyway. Because AI can't think for us.

Thanks for reading,

Ashley R. Cummings


Sponsored by: The Rundown AI

Start learning AI in 2025

Everyone talks about AI, but no one has the time to learn it. So, we found the simplest way to learn AI in as little time as possible: The Rundown AI.

It's a free AI newsletter that keeps you up-to-date on the latest AI news, and teaches you how to apply it in just 5 minutes a day.

Plus, complete the quiz after signing up and they’ll recommend the best AI tools, guides, and courses – tailored to your needs.


Cool New Jobs


Expert Interview | Polly Clover

1. Tell me more about yourself and your journey into content.

I'm a former teacher turned writer. In 2018, I quit my teaching job in the States to move to and teach in Vietnam. Pretty quickly, I stopped teaching because I wanted to work remotely and travel around Southeast Asia.

I dabbled in blog writing for a bit and eventually dove more into freelance writing when I decided I didn't want to become an employee again.

After moving back stateside in 2020, I started my writing business full-time. I'm now an SEO writer and consultant, so I help people get their websites on Google. Most of my work is SEO-friendly blog writing, which I love! It's such a fun way to write helpful content and generate strong leads, and I love how evergreen website SEO marketing is.

2. What is one evolving search trend content marketers can't afford to ignore in 2025?

In 2025, we must meet people's desire to read real-life experiences and recommendations. People get bored quickly, and they need a reason to read content.

Content needs to be authentic and relatable to connect with readers. Relevant examples and personal experiences help with this. We can also use sources for this if needed.

In technical terms, this is known as E-E-A-T, which stands for Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness. Not only are Google's ranking systems looking for content that demonstrates E-E-A-T, but it's also beneficial in any content writing on any platform where you want to build trust with an audience.


Partner 2.0 | Ranked

I signed up for a new SEO service, Ranked. I'm loving it. I no longer have to do the SEO for my sites and am watching my rankings rise. You can get started for free today.


The Best in Content This Week

Read these and get even smarter:

1/ Google announced the Discover feed is coming to Google (John Shehata - LI)

Google Discover is coming to desktop — and it could mean 15% more traffic for publishers. Here's what you need to know.

2/ 5 thoughts on doing more with less (Tracey Wallace)

Tracey Wallace shares five sharp insights for content marketers navigating AI disruption, shifting goals, and the demand to deliver fast without losing quality. Plus, why product marketing should be your North Star.

3/ The intersection of content marketing and journalism (Kaleigh Moore)

Why aren't more brands using journalists for content marketing? Kaleigh Moore breaks down how freelance writers can pitch newsworthy angles clients actually want, and why brands need to think more like publishers if they want to stand out.


Let's (Content) Connect

Social

Services

Resources

  • Free community: Join 142K other content marketers.
  • Resources: Get the freelance writing template bundle, contractor agreement, and content brief.

Digital nomad life

  • Subscribe to Life In A Backpack: This newsletter includes stories & tips and access to a free community of other nomads + worldschoolers.

👇 Ad | Click To Learn More

113 Cherry St #92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2205
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Content Connect

Subscribe now to grow your content marketing and writing muscles! Each week, you'll get an expert interview from a leading content marketer (free consulting—yay!), quick & actionable writing tips, and content marketing trends you may have missed delivered straight to your inbox. It's an easy decision—join 7000 other content marketers now!

Read more from Content Connect
Where to get expert insights for articles

Hello Reader! Keeping it short today, since I've already popped in your inbox this week with a freebie (free content brief). Get the free brief now if you missed out This week, we have some awesome job opportunities (below or here) and killer industry articles (including 2 places to get expert insights). Keep scrolling for details! Thanks, Ashley R. Cummings Partner | Harlow Join the 9k+ freelancers and creators turning to Harlow to find new clients and build thriving businesses. Hundreds of...

Hello Reader! I wanted to say a quick 'thank you' to all of you amazing subscribers and offer you a free gift. (Today only!) Ever spent hours writing a draft… only to get vague feedback like “this isn’t quite right”? Worse—had to start from scratch because the content missed the mark? I’ve been there. That’s why I created a content brief template to help writers and content teams get clear before they even start. With the brief, you'll: ✅ Know exactly what needs to be written✅ Stay aligned...

Hello Reader! The further we plunge into the AI-can-just-do-content-for-us world, the more this life lesson rings true to me: The things most worth doing are hard. AI relationships aren't hard to maintain. The robots adapt to you. They don't challenge you. You never have to have a tough conversation. They pad your ego. You're always a winner, but you never grow. Marriage is hard. I'm personally going on 14 years navigating life with my polar opposite. It's not always easy, but we challenge...